The Ultimate Creamy Vanilla Cinnamon Body Butter - Pronounce Skincare & Herbal Boutique - featured picture

The Ultimate Creamy Vanilla Cinnamon Body Butter

Today we are talking about the Ultimate Creamy Vanilla Cinnamon Body Butter!!! Made up of rich vitamins, unsaturated fats, and protein intense shea butter, coconut oil, sweet almond oil, and more. Bonus additions for your sense of smell...pure vanilla extract and cinnamon. These two ingredients give this the most wonderful warming scent.

Honestly, you’ll smell like a cinnamon sugar cookie all day...

And possibly the best part of making your own DIY body butter is knowing exactly what’s in it, avoiding all of those harmful ingredients often found in butters on store shelves.

First, what’s the difference between body butter and lotion anyway?

And does it really matter?

It can be confusing to know which one to reach for with sooooooo many products and DIY recipes out there!

Let’s break it down:

  • Lotions typically work well on normal to oily areas of the skin. They work quickly to lubricate and soften the skin.

  • Body butters work best on dry areas of the skin and is not absorbed quickly. Body butters is thicker in nature, and therefore stay on the skin longer adding up to deep moisture penetration over time.

What makes body butter a deep moisturizer?

Simply put, it’s the ingredients that allow body butter to retain moisture and nourish the skin.

Body butter ingredients includes a combination of natural butters, carrier oils, and specialized ingredients. And, they rarely contain water or hydrosols, which is the exact opposite of lotion. 

Learn more about the benefits of natural buttersincluding a printable guide, and learn about carrier oils in our comprehensive guide to all things carrier oils. Click here for a comprehensive guide to the differences between body butters and body lotions.

Below are examples of ingredients that make body butter so amazing!

Natural Butters:

Carrier Oils:

  • Coconut oil
  • Sweet almond oil
  • Avocado oil
  • Jojoba oil

Specialized Ingredients:

  • Aloe vera gel
  • Vitamin E oil
  • Honey
  • Rosehip seed oil
  • Essential oils

When should you use body butter?

Many turn to body butter in the winter because colder temps often mean dry, irritated skin. Honestly, you can reach for body butter anytime you need intensive moisturizing!

Ready to make your own body butter?

This body butter recipe is the perfect combination of natural ingredients when you’re skin needs little extra hydration, winter weather or not.

The Ultimate Creamy Vanilla Cinnamon Body Butter (16oz)


  • Double-boiler- I make my own with a glass bowl over a simmering pot of shallow H2O.
  • Container(s)- This recipe yields appx. 16oz. You'll find 16oz glass jars and 8oz jar options in my Herbal Boutique.
  • 6 T Shea Butter - Raw, organic, unrefined shea butter
  • 6 T Cocoa Butter - Raw, organic, unrefined cocoa butter
  • 1/2 C Coconut Oil - Hand-pressed, organic coconut oil
  • 1 t Sweet Almond Oil - Unrefined, cold-pressed, organic sweet almond oil
  • 1 t Ground Cinnamon - Organic ground cinnamon
  • 1/4 t Cinnamon Essential Oil - (see note below)
  • 2 t Vanilla Extract - Organic vanilla extract

*t = teaspoon T = tablespoon C = cup

Make It

Add both shea butter and cocoa butter in your double broiler. After they melt add coconut oil and ground cinnamon. Allow time to melt fully.

Mix well with a whisk while melting. Once everything is melted, add sweet almond oil to the mixture. Whisk well to fully combine. Place the melted mixture in refrigerator for one hour or until firm. You don't want this to be totally solid, but it does need to be firm. Think the texture of a stick of butter.

Remove from the refrigerator and whip until creamy and light using a hand mixer. Add vanilla extract and cinnamon essential oil.

Mix once more with a hand mixer to blend. Spoon creamy vanilla cinnamon body butter into airtight containers.

NOTE: If it seems extra moist after whipping, no worries it will firm up after a few minutes.

NOTE: Cinnamon essential oil is classified as a “hot oil.” It may tingle or cause irritation for those with sensitive skin. If you haven’t used cinnamon essential oil before you should try it first on a small area of skin blended with a carrier oil. You can always choose to omit it from the this recipe, too. It will still smell a like a cinnamon sugar cookie, wink...wink.


What’s the Best Way to Apply Body Butter?

Body butter works best when applied to damp skin to help reduce loss of moisture. Therefore I recommend applying it right out of the shower. But keep in mind, it’s a heavier product, so you don’t need much.

It typically takes longer to sink into the skin meaning five to ten minutes. During that time it may leave a slight oily barrier depending on your skin type.

Body butter can be pore clogging, which is why you may want to avoid applying it to your face. It is quite ideal for the hands, feet, legs, arms, elbows, and knees.

Whip a jar of the Ultimate Creamy Vanilla Cinnamon Body Butter to nourish your skin anytime you need an intense moisturizer. The sweet yummy scent alone it worth the effort! If you love this recipe you’ll love DIY Pumpkin Lavender Body Buttertoo to keep up with the seasonal temperature drops.


Not feeling particularly DIYish?

Simply not enough hours in the day? Pinning more than you could ever tackle these days? No worries. I have got you covered. Please, head on over to my Pronounce Skincare Shop where I sell my own version of a handcrafted body butter. While you are there, please look around at all of my other skincare creations. I love making them for my family and for you!

Comments 14

  1. I want to try this but am not very fond of cinnamon so can I omit both the cinnamon oil and ground cinnamon. If I do so will I get the same results?

    1. Post
  2. Pingback: DIY Detangling Spray (Perfect for sensitive heads) • Pronounce Skincare & Herbal Boutique

  3. Just made this! I can’t stop sniffing myself! I made a batch for my mama for Mother’s Day! Oh I know she is going to love it. Thank you so much Jess!

    1. Post

      Oh my goodness…that is an awesome gift to give. How sweet! I hope you made some extra for you. 😉 I’m glad that you love it and I”m sure mom will, too.

  4. This sounds amazing. I can’t use any of the “commercial” lotions or body butters, and I’d love to try my hand at making my own. Thanks for giving me the confidence to try it!

    1. Post
  5. Hi, I would like to know why you haven’t used a weight measurement as in previous recipes. I’m sure you have said that it’s more accurate to weigh ingredients and I prefer that method as well.

    1. Post

      Hi Sharifa! Great question. I also prefer using ounces or grams and measuring with a scale, but to make DIYing more relatable and doable for the masses (if you would) sometimes I think it’s a-okay to use simple teaspoon and tablespoon measurements.

      I think most people have access to t and T utensils, and honestly…for a recipe like this you don’t really have to be perfectly exact. Just being close in measurement is great for a recipe like this. Now, for sunscreen, foundation, and a few others…I really, really prefer more exact measurements and using a scale. But…writing this recipe like this I thought was helpful to make the recipe more accessible for all. If anyone wants to, there are loads of free measurement converter calculators online (I use one almost daily). Great question, and happy DIYing for you!

  6. Holy moly, I don’t know whether to put this on my skin or just eat it! The scent sounds amazing. I need to make it asap!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.